Fair monetization and rejection of pay-to-win

Fair monetization is presented as a non-negotiable requirement for a good MMORPG. The central claim is that once players can buy power directly, trust in the game is damaged.

Pay-to-win and convenience sales

Direct pay-to-win is rejected outright. The discussion also treats some forms of so-called convenience monetization with suspicion, especially when they function as indirect power sales. Examples mentioned include boosts, loot boxes, and gear skips.

The criticism is not limited to explicit stat purchases. Any system that makes players feel that spending money is more effective than playing well is framed as harmful to the MMO experience.

Preferred monetization model

The preferred model focuses on cosmetics, expansions, and optional services. This approach is presented as a way to fund ongoing development without undermining fairness or progression integrity.

The guiding principle is that a player's wallet should not be stronger than the player's in-game effort.

Source

• Recording: What Actually Makes A GOOD MMORPG
• YouTube: Watch on YouTube
• Published: Thursday, August 28, 2025 at 2:10 PM UTC